Broker Transparency - lack of understanding

See this topic come up so much on here and LinkedIn.

Curious what is causing the carriers to push this? They think brokers are ripping $1000 every load or something?

Also if they do get this passed, what’s the benefit to them? I’m sure they’d have signed some stuff that states they can’t take that information to the customer or competitors, so what they’d know to raise their rate next time if they see you made $750?

I have some clients we make $1000, then lose $250 and lose $300, then make $500. Huge swings either way.

What is a carrier going to do with this information finding out the broker maybe made a pop?